Can My Wooden Floor Be Refinished?

Hey there, amazing readers! It's Patrick, your friendly hardwood enthusiast, back for another exciting exploration into the world of home transformation. Now, let me set the scene for you – picture this: you stroll into a room, and bam! Your eyes are greeted by the warm, inviting glow of a hardwood floor. That timeless elegance, that classic charm – it's a vibe that's hard to beat.

But, here's the scoop – even the most beautiful things need a little tender loving care to stay on top of their game. Enter stage left: hardwood floor refinishing. It's like a magical makeover for your floors, breathing new life into them, making them look as fresh as the day they were installed, and adding precious years to their lifespan. Exciting, right?

Now, I get it. The world of hardwood floor refinishing might seem like a bit of a maze, especially if you're just getting started. But fret not, my friends! This guide is your personal lantern in the labyrinth, ready to illuminate every step of the way. From figuring out if your floor is refinishing-ready to keeping that newfound radiance alive, we're leaving no stone unturned.

So, are you ready to sprinkle some fairy dust on your hardwood floors and bring back their former glory? Well then, grab your metaphorical toolbelt, because we're about to dive headfirst into the wonderful world of hardwood floor refinishing. Let the adventure begin!

Key Takeaways

  • Assess your hardwood floor’s potential for refinishing by evaluating its type, wear layer and signs of damage.

  • Repair any damage before refinishing to avoid Issues. The process involves sanding, staining and finishing.

  • Regular maintenance is key to extend the lifespan of refinished floors by protecting them from wear and tear.

Assessing Your Hardwood Floor's Refinishing Potential

old maple flooring

Removing an old Maple floor that was too damaged for refinishing

Before you even start the task of refinishing a wooden floor, it’s important to first very closely evaluate the condition of your hardwood floors. Are they solid wood or engineered? How worn is the top layer? Are there telltale signs that a refinishing is in order? Answering these questions is key to prevent undertaking a task that may be too challenging, or a task that may not even be possible. Understanding each of these aspects will help you better gauge your floor’s refinishing potential.

First off, I’ll identify the type of hardwood flooring that you have. Knowing your floor type can make all the difference in the world when it comes to refinishing. It’ll also help you better prepare for the project. Next, we’ll measure the wear layer of your floor. A floor with a thick wear layer is a green light for refinishing, while a thin one might necessitate replacement rather than refinishing. Last but not least, I’ll guide you to better recognize the signs that your floor might need a refinish.

Ready? Let’s get started!

first sanding pass brazilian cherry

The first sanding pass on a very old Brazilian Cherry hardwood floor

Identifying the Type of Hardwood Floor That You Have

Are you aware that your hardwood floor type can have a significant impact on its refinishing capabilities? From oak to acacia, from hickory to walnut, each species of hardwood has its own unique characteristics and refinishing needs.

Solid wood floors like oak or hickory can be refinished multiple times, making them an excellent choice for high-traffic areas. Conversely, engineered wood floors, made of a solid wood veneer on a plywood base, may not hold up as well to refinishing. While their rustic charm and wide planks can be a feast for the eyes, the thin veneer can only withstand a limited number of refinishes. Usually just one or two at most. So make sure you know your proper floor type before you start the refinishing process. Now is also a good time to look into whether you’re going to go with an oil-based finish or a water-based finish as well. Check out some of my other blog posts where I discuss the main differences between the two! You can find all of my other blog posts here.

Measuring the Wear Layer

engineered floor wear layer

The wear layer of an engineered wooden floorboard

If the type of hardwood floor is the soul of your refinishing project, then the wear layer is its heartbeat. The wear layer is the top layer of your floor that endures the most from daily activities. Every scratch, every scuff, every piece of furniture dragged across it, all these activities wear down this top layer over time. This top layer is the only part of the floor that can be refinished. Once the wear layer is sanded through, the floor will begin cracking and falling apart.

To determine whether your hardwood floor is a good candidate for refinishing, you’ll need to measure this wear layer. The process is quite straightforward and involves using a drill bit, a pinless meter, and a thermo-hygrometer. A wear layer of at least 3/32 of an inch or 2.5mm is typically necessary for a successful refinishing. Anything less than this, and you might need to consider replacing your floor instead of refinishing it. Most times, you can pretty safely eyeball this wear layer.

Signs You Might Need to Refinish

Now that you’ve identified your floor type and measured the wear layer, it’s time to look for signs that your floor might need a refinish. These signs are like a cry for help from your hardwood floors, signaling that it’s time for some TLC.

The most common signs that your hardwood floors need to be refinished include:

  • Visible scratches

  • Dents that are becoming more noticeable or have altered the color of the wood

  • Fading, particularly in rooms with rugs

  • Water damage, manifested by spots on the wood or darkened areas

If you notice any of these signs, it might be time for a refinish.

The Lifespan of Hardwood Floors and Refinishing

One of the many beauties of hardwood floors is their impressive lifespan. With the right care, solid wood floors can last a lifetime, or even longer! But like any long-lived entity, your hardwood flooring may need a little pick-me-up every now and then to keep them looking their best.

Refinishing can significantly extend the lifespan of your hardwood floors, but it might not always be the suitable solution. There comes a time when replacement, not refinishing, is the best course of action. But, for most homeowners, a good solid refinishing will fix 99% of the issues on your floors.

When to Say Goodbye

While it’s true that hardwood floors have an impressive lifespan, they’re not immortal, and they’re certainly not concrete. Eventually, the wear and tear of everyday life will take its toll, and your floors will reach the end of their lifespan. Common signs that it’s time for a replacement include mold or rot over the hardwood, extreme wear, and compromised integrity. If you can literally feel the floors giving in below your feet, chances are you can’t refinish them anymore.

When to Refinish

For most homeowners, it will really just come down to the physical appearance of the flooring. If the floors are developing a lot of scratches, or if you are noticing that the top polyurethane layer of the floors is almost no longer existent, then it is certainly time for a refinishing. A telltale sign that the protective layer of your floors is too worn down is when the wooden flooring itself starts to turn black and dirty in color.

Below, is a picture of a floor we recently redid in Chicago. As you can tell on the top left corner, you can see the floors had been so worn down in spots that there wasn’t even any finish remaining! So all of the dirt and grime from walking over the floors was just getting ingrained deeper and deeper into the raw wood of the floors. This causes them to look more and more “dirty”.

old hardwood floor in chicago

A very old floor in the city. Notice the discoloration, black dirt\grime, and all of the scuffs as well as scratches

new rubio monocoat hardwood floors chicago

Same floor, same angle after a full sanding + finishing with Rubio Monocoat Hardwax Oil

rubio monocoat floors chicago

Same floor finished with Rubio Monocoat, different angle

Preparing for the Refinishing Process

So, you’ve assessed your hardwood floors and determined that they’re good candidates for refinishing. Great! Now it’s time to roll up your sleeves and prepare for the refinishing process. Before you start sanding, make sure your floors are in the best condition possible.

This might involve fixing any issues like loose boards, gaps, or protruding nail heads. It might also involve a bit of patching to ensure that the refinishing process goes smoothly.

But don’t worry, most of these repairs are simple and can be done with basic tools. For example:

  • You can tighten loose boards with a few nails

  • You can fill in deep scratches and big gaps with wood putty

  • If you encounter any nails sticking out of the floor, you can hammer them down with a nail set. Afterwards, fill the hole with wood filler

The Refinishing Process

lagler trio floor sanding chicago

The first sanding pass on a hardwood floor with our fancy pants Lagler Trio sander

Now that your floors are in their best shape, it’s time to refinish them. This is a multi-step process that involves sanding, staining, and finishing. Each step is crucial to achieving a beautiful and durable finish. I’ve got plenty of blog posts that can guide you through this process step by step.

Don’t be intimidated by the process. With the right tools and a bit of patience, you can breathe new life into your floors. Here are the general refinishing process steps.

Sanding Your Floors

sanding flooring wilmette

Sanding the edges of a hardwood floor before the next Lagler Trio sanding pass

Sanding is the first step in the refinishing process and perhaps the most important one. It involves removing the old finish and smoothing out any imperfections on your floors. This step is crucial in preparing your floors for the new finish.

To sand your floors, you’ll need a drum or belt sander, a dust mask, and a bit of elbow grease. Start with a coarse grit sandpaper to remove the old finish and gradually move on to finer grits for a smooth finish. Remember to always sand in the direction of the wood grain to avoid scratches and uneven surfaces.

Staining and Choosing Finishes

After sanding your floors, you can start adding color. Staining your floors can enhance the natural beauty of the wood and give your floors a fresh new look. Plus, it allows you to customize the look of your floors to match your home’s decor.

When choosing a stain for your floors, consider the type of wood and the overall look you’re going for. Light stains can bring out the natural grain of the wood, while dark stains can add a touch of elegance and sophistication. Once you’ve chosen a stain, it’s time to apply a finish to protect your floors and keep them looking great for years to come.

Cost Considerations for Refinishing Hardwood Floors

buffing stain wilmette

Applying stain with a floor buffer

Refinishing your hardwood floors is a worthwhile investment. Not only does it enhance the look of your floors, but it also increases their lifespan. However, like any home improvement project, it comes with many challenges and a cost. From hiring a professional to doing it yourself, the cost of refinishing your hardwood floors can vary based on several factors.

So, how much is the expected cost of refinishing your hardwood floors? And is it more cost-effective to do it yourself or hire a professional? I’ll try to quickly touch on these questions as I close out this blog post.

DIY vs. Professional Refinishing

If you’re handy and have some time to spare, you might consider refinishing your floors yourself. DIY refinishing can save you a pretty penny, but it does require a significant amount of time and effort. Plus, you’ll need to rent or buy the necessary equipment, which, if not planned properly, can end up costing you more then just hiring someone to do it.

Hiring a professional to refinish your floors can save you time and ensure a high-quality finish. However, professional services come with a higher price tag, typically ranging from $5 to $10 per square foot around our area. Weigh the pros and cons of each option to decide which is the best fit for your budget and schedule.

Maintaining Your Refinished Hardwood Floors

engineered hardwood flooring chicago

Freshly finished hardwood floors with Rubio Monocoat 2c Pure

After refinishing your hardwood floors, it’s important to maintain their appearance. Regular maintenance can extend the lifespan of your floors and prevent the need for another refinishing down the line.

Proper maintenance involves more than just regular cleaning. It also means protecting your floors from everyday wear and tear. Let’s examine some methods to maintain the look of your refinished floors.

Protecting Against Wear and Tear

Take the following steps to protect and maintain your hardwood floors:

  • Place felt pads under your furniture to prevent scratches

  • Avoid wearing shoes or heels in the house to minimize dirt, dents, and grime

  • Use products specifically designed for hardwood floors when cleaning

  • Stay away from any cleaning products claiming to “shine up” your floors

With these safety measures in place, you can enjoy the newly refinished hardwood floors in your home for many years to come.

Summary

Revitalizing your hardwood floors is truly a rewarding adventure, one that can infuse a whole new energy into your living space. I've had a blast being your guide on this journey, sharing insights from assessing your floors’ refinishing potential to preserving their newfound radiance. Think of it as a roadmap to a home transformation, crafted just for you!

Now, I understand that diving into the refinishing world might seem like stepping into the unknown, but fear not, because armed with the right knowledge and a dash of enthusiasm, you're fully equipped to restore your floors to their magnificent best. Picture it – the warmth, the glow, the sheer timeless elegance that your hardwood floors are about to exude!

Ready to embark on this exciting venture? Why not kickstart your refinishing journey today? Your floors are eagerly awaiting the magic touch that only you can provide. And hey, if you find yourself in need of a little extra guidance or want to explore professional flooring services, don’t hesitate to swing by our website. There, you’ll discover a treasure trove of tips, and on our contact page, you're just a message away from turning your hardwood dreams into reality. Here's to a future filled with the enduring beauty of your newly refreshed floors. Happy refinishing, friends! 🌟

Frequently Asked Questions

When can wood floors not be refinished?

Wood floors cannot be refinished if they are more than 150 years old, have extreme movement between boards, or have substantial structural problems that require the flooring to be removed and the subfloor fixed. In these cases, a replacement is necessary.

Is it cheaper to refinish floors or replace?

Refinishing your hardwood floors is almost always more cost effective than replacing them due to the additional costs associated with wood, installation, and labor.

Can damaged wood floors be refinished?

Yes, damaged wood floors can typically be refinished if the damage is minor enough. Floors with cracks, scratches, discoloration, mild warping, and gaps can all be repaired through sanding, refinishing, patching, etc.

What type of wood is best for flooring?

Oak flooring is the most popular choice for wood flooring due to its durability, color range and reasonable cost. Other good options include maple, cherry, bamboo, walnut, ash and mahogany, with more exotic species such as teak, jarrah and mesquite available at a higher cost.

How often should I refinish my hardwood floors?

It is recommended to assess the wear layer of your hardwood floor every 15 to 20 years in order to determine when refinishing is necessary.